Immigration misinformation in the US Today:
Countering lies in the 2024 Election Cycle with real data
Politicians lie all the time. We know this. They’ll say anything to get your vote. Lies about immigration and migrants in the U.S. have been used by politicians for decades. This election cycle has been no exception, with some anti-immigrant lies reaching arguably new highs. As misinformation about immigration in the U.S. continues to spread via politicians, pundits, and the media, a few mainstream media outlets have done a decent job of fact-checking these claims. These articles tend to reference one or two widely shared studies that disprove anti-immigrant claims and downright lies—with real, actual data. However, beyond the few studies that have been shared most widely, there is actually an expansive amount of research out there. University researchers, area experts, think tanks, non-profits, NGO’s, and journalists have done the good work of providing thorough, well researched, and common sense evidence and data that reveals the truth behind immigration in the U.S. The evidence is vast and at times overwhelming. So, I have begun putting together a living resource of studies, reports, and statistics regarding the realities of U.S. immigration today. The hope is that these resource lists will be useful to other researchers, writers, journalists, analysts, policy makers, and those simply interested in providing hard evidence in your feeds or in real-life conversations.
Click on the headings below to access a list of resources that disprove the corresponding false claim politicians and pundits spread. These resources only scratch the surface, so I will be adding to the lists as time goes on.
LIes and Myths about Immigration in the U.S.
Click through to explore the real data that disproves these common claims
-
Perhaps one of the most widespread lies told by politicians today is that there is a "migrant crime wave" currently afoot in the U.S. Speeches at this year's RNC repeated these claims with completely false and made up numbers. And the Harris campaign promotes these lies through promises to 'secure the southern border.'
-
Politicians often claim that immigrants are a drain on the economy, and are here to take your jobs. Both are very very false.
-
The American Immigration Council sums it up the best: “Repeated investigations over the years have found no indication that systematic vote fraud by non-citizens is anything other than the product of overactive imaginations.”
-
The republicans have been claiming that Biden and Harris are for open borders. This lie would be laughable if the truth didn’t have such horrific implications for the state of human and civil rights protections in the U.S.
Click here for the unfortunate reality behind the Dem's immigration policy.
Why They Lie
Politician’s, pundit’s, and the media’s portrayals of immigration as an “invasion,” “flood,” “crime wave,” and so on are not new. They have been a part of American history for a very long time. It is a tried and true means of garnering votes. Politicians lie to drum up perceptions of immigrants as something to be feared, then promise to keep those immigrants out (if you vote accordingly). It is an illusion through and through that has been used historically. Unfortunately, it often works. And this is not to mention all the campaign funding they get for it…
In my forthcoming book, titled “Migrant Justice in the Age of Removal,” coming out from UGA Press in 2025, I explore these issues.
Here are some brief excerpts on these issues, with links to the referenced studies.
Living Data
Here is a collection of searchable, live data and other resources for you to explore, research, and use to inform.
As with the rest of this page, I will be adding to this list as time goes on.